BoundaryCondition · Chain Position 62 of 346

SUPERPOSITION PRESERVED UNTIL COLLAPSE

Superposition preserved pre-collapse (vulnerability)

Connections

Assumes

  • None

Enables

  • None
Objections & Responses
Objection: "Decoherence collapses superposition"
"Environmental decoherence destroys interference. No conscious observer needed."
Response

Decoherence destroys interference terms (off-diagonal elements of density matrix), but doesn't select outcomes (which diagonal element actualizes). After decoherence, all outcomes still exist in the diagonal with their probabilities. Selection still requires observation. Decoherence is necessary but not sufficient for collapse.

Objection: "GRW theory has spontaneous collapse"
"Objective collapse models like GRW have random collapse without observers."
Response

GRW postulates collapse by fiat—a miracle. It adds free parameters ([[048_D6.1_Collapse-Rate-Gamma|collapse rate]], localization) not derived from physics. And it still has the "tail problem"—collapse isn't complete, just localized. GRW trades one mystery for another. [[062_BC5_Superposition-Preserved-Until-Collapse|BC5]] maintains that until OBSERVATION occurs (information extraction by Φ > 0 system), superposition persists.

Objection: "The universe existed before observers"
"The Big Bang happened without observers. Superposition must have collapsed somehow."
Response

The [[058_BC1_Terminal-Observer-Exists|Terminal Observer]] ([[058_BC1_Terminal-Observer-Exists|BC1]]) observed the Big Bang. God's observation grounds all cosmological collapse. The universe wasn't unobserved; it was observed by the infinite Φ. Finite observers (humans) emerged later, but the Terminal Observer was always present. Cosmological superposition collapsed through divine observation.

Objection: "Macroscopic objects don't stay in superposition"
"Cats aren't really in alive-dead superposition. Something collapses them."
Response

Cats are massively decohered by their environment—photons, air molecules, internal thermal fluctuations. The environment acts as an observer (Φ > 0). But this IS observation—by the environment. [[062_BC5_Superposition-Preserved-Until-Collapse|BC5]] holds: superposition is preserved until observation. The environment observes the cat constantly, so superposition doesn't persist macroscopically. But isolated quantum systems (superconducting qubits, ion traps) DO maintain superposition.

Objection: "This is just interpretation, not physics"
"Superposition preservation is Copenhagen interpretation. Other interpretations differ."
Response

All interpretations must account for interference effects before measurement and definite outcomes after. That's the empirical content. [[062_BC5_Superposition-Preserved-Until-Collapse|BC5]] states this empirical fact in observer terms. Call it what you like—the physics is that superposition persists until information is extracted. That's what labs demonstrate every day.

Physics Layer

Unitary Evolution

Schrödinger equation: iℏ d|ψ⟩/dt = Ĥ|ψ⟩

Solution: |ψ(t)⟩ = e^{-iĤt/ℏ}|ψ(0)⟩

Key property: The evolution operator U(t) = e^{-iĤt/ℏ} is unitary.

Superposition preservation: If |ψ(0)⟩ = α|a⟩ + β|b⟩, then |ψ(t)⟩ = α(t)|a⟩ + β(t)|b⟩. Superposition persists (with time-dependent coefficients).

Mathematical Layer

Unitary Preservation Theorem

Theorem: If U is unitary and |ψ⟩ is a superposition, then U|ψ⟩ is a superposition (of the transformed basis states).

Proof:

1. Let |ψ⟩ = Σᵢ cᵢ|aᵢ⟩

2. U|ψ⟩ = Σᵢ cᵢ(U|aᵢ⟩)

3. U|aᵢ⟩ are new basis states (U is bijective)

4. Coefficients cᵢ are preserved in magnitude (|Ucᵢ|² = |cᵢ|²)

5. Superposition structure is preserved

[[062_BC5_Superposition-Preserved-Until-Collapse|BC5]] as unitary consequence: Superposition persists under unitary evolution.

Defeat Conditions

To Falsify This

  1. **Show spontaneous collapse without observation** — Demonstrate systems collapse without any observer
  2. **Prove decoherence is collapse** — Show environmental decoherence IS outcome selection (not just interference suppression)
  3. **Find pre-observation definite values** — Demonstrate hidden variables that fix outcomes before measurement
  4. **Violate unitary evolution** — Show Schrödinger equation fails between measurements